AGENDA ITEM
TO: HONORABLE MAYOR
AND MEMBERS OF THE CITY COUNCIL
FROM: CARLO TOMAINO
CITY MANAGER
BY: YVETTE E. AGUILAR
DEPUTY CITY MANAGER
SUBJECT:
title
NAMING RIGHTS POLICY
summary
Summary:
On April 14, 2026, Councilmember Jones received consensus for staff to prepare an introductory agenda item to allow discussion of a potential naming rights policy. The City Council subsequently directed staff to establish a draft naming rights policy, consider any criteria that should be included in the policy, and present the draft policy for City Council consideration. The proposed Naming Policy includes the establishment of a City Council Ad-Hoc Committee to review naming requests along with criteria for consideration such as that the individual reflect the City’s values, mission, positive image, and that the individual’s work or life have contributed to the betterment of Signal Hill. Staff drafted a Naming Policy for the City Council’s review and consideration.
Strategic Plan Goal(s):
Goal No. 5: High-Functioning Government: Strengthen internal communication, recruitment, retention, systems, and processes to increase the effectiveness and efficiency of City services.
recommendation
Recommendation:
Staff recommends the City Council review and discuss the proposed Naming Rights Policy and provide staff with further direction.
body
Fiscal Impact:
There is minimal fiscal impact associated with the recommended action.
Background:
At the City Council meeting of April 14, 2026, Council Member Jones requested staff place an item on the agenda to discuss the potential of establishing Naming Policy; Council Member Woods provided a vote in support of additional discussion. Staff is including this item on the agenda for initial discussion based on a previously established City Council process. Pursuant to Section 6.1 of the City’s Manual of Procedural Guidelines, if a majority of the City Council supports placing this item on a subsequent agenda for further action, staff prepares a more detailed agenda report with additional analysis.
Analysis:
The primary purpose of the proposed policy (Policy) is to establish a clear, consistent, and transparent framework for naming and renaming City assets (Attachment A). The Policy would allow the City to recognize significant contributions and individuals who have made meaningful contributions to the community while ensuring that naming decisions are consistent with the City’s mission, values, history, and long-term interests. The Policy is not intended to create an automatic entitlement to naming rights based upon a donation. Rather, a donor may request consideration of a proposed name, but the naming of any City asset remains entirely within the discretion of the City Council.
Process and Initiation of a Naming Request
The consideration of naming or renaming a City asset may be initiated in either of two ways:
1. Significant Contribution
The City may consider naming a City asset at the request of a donor who has made a significant financial contribution to the City. A Significant Contribution would mean a donation or contribution of real property, goods, materials, or funds accepted by the City, for which there is no expectation of return, and which has a value exceeding $100,000. Funds received as a significant contribution may be used for any purpose determined appropriate by the City Council.
A donor seeking consideration of naming rights would be required to submit a written request to the City Manager. The request would include a statement summarizing the justification for the proposed name. The donor may propose a name; however, the proposed policy makes clear that the submission of a request or the making of a significant contribution does not guarantee naming rights. The donor’s proposed name would be subject to the City’s established criteria and the City Council’s approval.
2. City Council Initiated Request
A majority of the City Council may also direct staff to initiate the naming process for a City asset. Upon a majority vote of the City Council, the proposal would be forwarded to the Naming Committee for consideration under the criteria established by the policy.
Naming Committee
The proposed policy establishes an ad-hoc Naming Committee that may be appointed by the City Council. The Naming Committee would be responsible for evaluating naming and renaming proposals and providing recommendations to the City Council. The committee would be comprised of no more than two members of the City Council, appointed by the City Council at the time it is considering a proposal for naming or renaming rights. Committee members would serve for the duration of the consideration of the proposal and would cease serving upon completion of the Committee’s recommendation to the full City Council in their ad-hoc capacity. The Naming Committee would evaluate each proposal using the criteria established in the policy and provide its recommendation to the City Council which would retain full authority to accept, reject, or modify the recommendation of the Naming Committee.
City Council Review and Approval
Following receipt of a recommendation from the Naming Committee, the City Council would consider the proposal and its applicability to the Policy criteria. The City Council may also request or consider recommendations from other City bodies or advisory groups, as appropriate, including the Planning Commission, Parks and Recreation Commission, and Signal Hill Historical Society or advisory bodies deemed appropriate by the City Council. Importantly, the naming or renaming of a City asset would require the unanimous approval of the City Council. All decisions regarding the naming or renaming of a City asset would be made in open session at a public meeting.
Criteria for Naming and Renaming City Assets
The proposed policy provides several categories and criteria that may be considered when evaluating a proposed name.
1. Individuals or Families
City assets may be named after individuals or families who have made a significant contribution to the City or in honor of persons who have served the United States of America, the State of California, the County of Los Angeles, or the Signal Hill community in an exceptional and distinguished manner. The City may also consider individuals of significant social, cultural, historical, or civic importance. However, a City asset should not be named after an individual, organization, or entity in a manner that conflicts with the City’s image, mission, community values, or public interest.
2. Deceased Individuals
As a general guideline, a City asset should not be named in honor of a deceased individual until a minimum of one year following the individual’s passing, unless the City Council determines that overriding circumstances justify deviation from this guideline. The waiting period is intended to allow sufficient time for an individual’s accomplishments and contributions to be evaluated objectively and reduce the possibility that naming decisions are made primarily on the basis of immediate emotional response.
3. Geographic or Historical Names
City assets may also be named after places, geographic features, topographical characteristics, or historically significant locations associated with Signal Hill. Names should assist the public in identifying the location of a City asset. When considering a geographic or location-based name, the City Council may consider:
• The name of the surrounding community or area;
• Nearby geographic or topographical features;
• Adjacent schools;
• Nearby streets; and
• Other historically or geographically significant identifiers.
The City Council should also consider the past, present, and future history of the City asset and surrounding community.
4. General Naming Criteria
In considering any proposed name, the Naming Committee and City Council should determine whether the proposed name:
• Is in the best interest of the City;
• Provides a worthy and enduring legacy;
• Reflects the mission and vision of the City;
• Is appropriately located and remains relevant as the City grows, changes, and develops;
• Generates a strong and positive image for the community;
• Has broad public support; and
• Avoids undue commercialization of the City asset.
These criteria are intended to ensure that naming decisions remain focused on the long-term public interest rather than solely on the financial value of a contribution.
Renaming of City Assets
A request to rename an existing City asset would be evaluated using the same criteria applicable to the original naming decision. In addition, the Naming Committee and City Council would consider:
• The original justification for the existing name;
• The monetary value of prior significant contributions associated with the existing name;
• The history and significance of the existing name;
• The rationale for changing the name; and
• Whether circumstances have changed substantially since the original naming decision.
•
The City Council may determine that renaming is appropriate if circumstances have changed such that:
• The original purpose of the City asset has been significantly altered;
• The City asset has become obsolete or is no longer in use;
• The existing name is no longer an appropriate way to recognize the significant contribution associated with the asset; or
• Retaining the existing name conflicts with the City’s image, mission, community values, or public interest.
The proposed policy includes provisions to indicate that naming rights do not create an irrevocable right to maintain a particular name indefinitely. The City Council would retain discretion to revoke or change naming rights granted to an individual, organization, or entity when circumstances warrant.
Examples may include situations in which:
• The individual or entity becomes involved in criminal activity;
• The individual or entity engages in conduct involving moral turpitude;
• The individual or entity engages in conduct that is inconsistent with the City’s image, mission, or community values; or
• Other circumstances arise that make continued association with the individual or entity contrary to the City’s best interests.
Any decision to revoke or change naming rights would be made by the City Council in open session at a public meeting. The City Council would retain the ultimate authority and discretion to rename a City asset for any lawful reason consistent with the City’s policies and applicable law.
Conclusion
Adoption of a Naming Rights Policy would provide several benefits to the City. First, the Policy would establish a clear and consistent process for evaluating naming requests rather than requiring the City Council to develop procedures on a case-by-case basis. Second, the Policy would promote transparency and public confidence by establishing the criteria and approval process before a naming request is considered. Third, the Policy would provide a mechanism for the City to recognize individuals, families, organizations, and entities that make significant contributions to the community while ensuring that such recognition is consistent with the City’s long-term interests. Fourth, the Policy would protect the City from unintended consequences by establishing provisions addressing commercialization, changing circumstances, renaming, and the City’s continuing discretion over public assets. Finally, the Policy would ensure that naming decisions are considered from a long-term community perspective, rather than being based solely on the amount or nature of a particular contribution.
For the aforementioned reasons, staff recommends that City Council consider the proposed policy and provide staff with direction to formally adopt the Naming Rights Policy.
Reviewed for Fiscal Impact:
_________________________
Siamlu Cox
Attachment(s):
A. Draft Naming Rights Policy